Pollution and health risks exists at every point along the
nuclear weapons’ development chain, from the initial mining and milling
operations to the enrichment process, and finally from testing nuclear devices.
In this two-part series I will examine each of those areas and the health
risks associated with them.
In this first part, I will give a short introduction to the
history of North Korea’s nuclear program and then discuss the health risks
found within the uranium mining and milling process and the production of
nuclear fuel. (Read Part II here)
Introduction
North Korea can trace its nuclear program to soon after the
Korean War. After the war’s total devastation, Kim Il Sung vowed that the
country would never again be flattened, and he sought Soviet assistance in
creating Pyongyang’s own nuclear deterrent. Marshall Stalin and future Soviet
leaders weren’t too keen on Kim’s aspirations initially, but they did offer
help with the development of nuclear power and signed a nuclear cooperation
agreement in 1959. Never one to let an opportunity go to waste, Kim Il Sung
ordered secret research into building the A-bomb.
Yongbyon, North Korea’s main nuclear research center, was
constructed in the 1960s with help from the Soviet Union. Further facilities
across the country were constructed that were needed to mine the uranium, mill
it, and finally, to enrich it. The country has two known milling facilities,
one at at Pakchon and Pyongsan, and around dozen suspected uranium mining
sites. Pakchon and Pyongsan process low-grade coal to concentrate the uranium
naturally found within it (at relatively
low concentrations)
and then to turn it into yellowcake where the uranium concentration reaches
80%. From there it is sent to additional facilities including Yongbyon, some of
which have likely not been declared by North Korea to the international
community.
Mining and milling
North Korea is one of only seven countries that are not
signatories to the International Labor Organization. This United Nations agency
sets international labor standards, including those for nuclear research and
industry. Furthermore, the country’s mining sector is notoriously dangerous and
lacks modern safety precautions and necessary equipment. Injuries and
respiratory diseases are common, particularly in coal mines which is where
North Korea gets the bulk of its uranium. The country’s two largest uranium
mines, Pyongsan and Woogi-ri (within the Undok-Rason area), hold an estimated
11.5
million tonnes of ore and employ thousands of workers.
The inhuman treatment of workers at Pyongsan, and severe
negligence regarding monitoring radiation exposure and air quality was given in
testimony
by Dr. Shin Chang-hoon before the U.S House in 2014.
Once the ore leaves the mines, it is transported to the milling
plants to be converted into yellowcake. Even though coal itself is generally
considered safe to handle, every form of uranium extraction leaves behind
dangerous waste.
"regardless
of how uranium is extracted from rock, the processes leave behind radioactive
waste....The tailings remain radioactive and contain hazardous chemicals from
the recovery process."
Google Earth image
showing the residue of leaked waste material at both ends of the waste transfer
pipe.
The Pyongsan milling plant is a prime example of the
environmental damage done within North Korea’s nuclear sector. Satellite
imagery shows that the country’s primary milling facility has been
spilling
industrial waste into the Ryesong River for decades, and that the waste
material reservoir is unlined. This can allow contaminated water to seep into
groundwater supplies and also contaminate crops. Hundreds of thousands live
within the area of Pyongsan and downriver of the plant.
Non-proliferation expert Dr. Jeffrey Lewis summed it up
nicely in 2015 when he
said,
“
What is definitely happening, though, is that North Korea is dumping the
tailings from the plant into an unlined pond, one surrounded by farms. That’s
not a hypothetical harm. That’s actual pollution that is harming the
health and well being of the local community."
At Pakchon, which began uranium milling around 1982, a
former waste reservoir is now covered in cultivated land. This practice can be
seen at many mining and industrial sites. If the waste isn’t properly covered,
any crops grown over this material may become contaminated with heavy metals
such as vanadium and chromium, as well as lead and arsenic. Those contaminates
are passed up the food-chain into animals and humans.
Image showing that a
former waste reservoir is now farmland and the plant’s proximity to a river.
According
to defector Kim Tae-ho, who worked at Pakchon in the 1990s, when the
“experimental plant” would operate, yellow smoke would fill the plant and cause
“severe difficult breathing and unbearable pain.” The short-term effect
of inhaling yellowcake particles is primarily kidney damage which will resolve
itself unless there is recurrent exposure (such as from working at the site each
day). However, the main radiological risk comes from the radioactive gas radon
and its non-gaseous “
daughters”
like polonium-218. Improperly vented air can lead to a build up of these
radioactive materials and will cause immediate tissue damage to the lungs and
mucus membranes. Additionally, the use of acids in the production process
raises the risk for inhalation of sulfur-containing gases (which can have a
yellow tint to them) and cause irritation and eventually burns to the eyes and
lungs.
Pakchon and Pyongsan are combined mine and milling
facilities, but illnesses and food contamination have been reported at stand-alone
mines as well, such as at the Walbisan uranium mine (near Sunchon).
Sources
told
Radio
Free Asia that, “
local residents are forced to eat radioactive food and
drink radioactive water,” and “
[i]n Tongam village, the miners and their
families suffer from incurable diseases or various types of cancer. In
particular, many people die of liver cancer.”
Enrichment and fuel production
Even within the
uranium enrichment compound, almost every inch of available land has been
cultivated.
The next steps along the nuclear development chain happen at
Yongbyon. The complex exists as a closed-city and people are not free to enter
or exit without permission. Scientists, engineers, and others may work for many
years within the fenced off complex. They will marry and will raise children.
While being able to work within a prominent field brings
many benefits, it also brings risks. Brief exposure to radiation is rarely
dangerous. Short exposure risks are also not catastrophic when it comes to
inheritable genetic damage, either, as the world learned from the survivors of
Hiroshima and Nagasaki. But continual exposure because you’re living in a
contaminated environment increases those risks each day. This concern grows
when you consider that in recent years, dozens of new buildings have
been
constructed with room for thousands more residents.
Scientists who were involved during the early days of
Yongbyon’s operation have been
reported to
have suffered from wasting illnesses and hair loss.
Fast-forward to 2019, a former resident of Yongbyon told
DailyNK,
"In other
districts it is very difficult to find people with cleft lip but here there are
many individuals with crooked mouths, those lacking eyebrows, incidents of
dwarfism, and those with six fingers. There are even children who just look
like bare bones."
Adults can also be
affected,
with the most severe cases eventually causing mental deficiencies, cancers, and
wide array of other illnesses at relatively young ages.
The aforementioned Dr. Shin Chang-hoon also interviewed a
defector who worked at Yongbyon. He was told that the dosimeters (which measure
radiation exposure) were only checked every three months and workers were not
told of the results unless they had already begun to exhibit signs of radiation
sickness.
Adjacent to an area
of improperly stored nuclear waste is a grove of
dying trees and
farmland. It is only separated from the waste by a covering of dirt.
Improper disposal of radioactive materials can pollute the
soil, kill trees, and contaminate any food that is grown in the area. Releases
of gases into the atmosphere will likewise blanket the region and small,
aerosolized particles will eventually make their way down to the ground,
bringing with them radiation or forming toxic compounds. These gases can travel
for many miles and place other sites within North Korea at greater risk, not
just the immediate Yongbyon complex.
Concern over Yongbyon is especially grave considering the
large number of nuclear and chemical facilities in such a small area. Not just
in terms of ongoing dangers that defectors have told the world about, but also
in terms of a future accident, flood, or fire that could devastate the region
and require international intervention to solve.
The fact North Korea is largely cut off from the world and often
must rely on outdated science, manufacturing techniques, and potentially unreliable
indigenously produced parts and equipment means that the risk of accidents and
errors is greater than in other nuclear countries. It is something of a small
miracle that a large-scale incident hasn’t already occurred.
I would like to thank my current
Patreon supporters: Kbechs87, GreatPoppo, and Planefag.
--Jacob Bogle, 12/22/2019
Patreon.com/accessdprk
JacobBogle.com
Facebook.com/accessdprk
Twitter.com/JacobBogle
